Skip links

This Might Surprise You: Joe Theismann

Memories of Joe Theismann, with his thick eye black and bright single-bar facemask, are often synonymous with the Washington Redskins (now known as the Washington Commanders). But what if he hadn’t worn number 7 for the red and gold?

Joe Thiesmann Drafted by Miami Dolphins

That almost was the case as Theismann, a collegiate star for Notre Dame, was actually drafted by the Miami Dolphins in 1971. Theismann, however, declined Miami’s offer of $55,000 over three years. That’s right, $55,000 over three years. Theismann asked for that amount, but the stickler was a $35,000 bonus Theismann would owe back if he missed any of the three seasons. Joe opted for the Canadian Football League’s Toronto Argonauts. Had Theismann been drafted in 2022, his minimum NFL salary would have been over $700,000.

In 1974, Washington traded for Theismann’s rights, and he jumped straight into the lineup – as a punt returner. He didn’t start at quarterback until 1976.

Embed from Getty Images

What Might Have Been?

At the time Theisman was drafted, Bob Griese had been the Dolphins’ starter since 1967. He led them to the playoffs in 1970 before three consecutive Super Bowls in the following years. It’s possible that Theismann might have toiled in obscurity until 1980, when Griese suffered a career-ending shoulder injury. It’s also possible Griese would have lost his job to Theismann in 1972 after Griese went down in Week 5 with a dislocated ankle and broken leg.

Embed from Getty Images


For the two quarterbacks, things turned out as well as they could have. Griese went on to the Hall of Fame, and Theismann went on to win Super Bowl 17 with Washington. Ironically, the Super Bowl win came against the Dolphins — after Griese’s career had ended.

Theismann didn’t produce the game’s most memorable moments, however, throwing two interceptions in the second half while Miami clung to a slim lead. John Riggins proved to be the game’s hero, with a 43-yard rumble on 4th and 1 that proved to be the winning touchdown. Theismann also quarterbacked Washington to Super Bowl 18, a 38-9 thumping at the hands of the Los Angeles Raiders.

It wasn’t the first time Raiders quarterback Jim Plunkett took the spotlight from Theismann: Theismann finished second to Plunkett in the voting for the 1970 Heisman Trophy.

Hear More on The Game Before the Money Podcast:

Looking for a great NFL history book? Check out The Game Before the Money: Voices of the Men Who Built the NFL available at — Amazon.com – Barnes and Noble – University of Nebraska Press

Like sports history? Listen to The Game Before the Money Podcast! Most episodes include stories from legendary football stars.

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

  1. Joe Theismann & Norman Einstein | The Game Before the Money
  2. While Riggo’s run is most memorable of SBXVII. It is Theismann’s play to break up the sure interception by Bokamper that saved the game for the #HTTR